Chapter IV

How a pigeon finds its way

After fifty years of research we understand well how a pigeon holds a direction. How it knows where it is, however, is something researchers still do not agree on.

The country a pigeon comes to know: roads, rivers, church towers.

Researchers describe homing as map and compass. First the pigeon works out where it is in relation to its loft, then it uses a compass to hold that direction. The compass is well understood. Where the map comes from is, after fifty years, still an open question, and that is what makes this chapter so interesting: here you read what is settled, and what is still disputed.

The sun as a compass

The German researcher Gustav Kramer showed in the early fifties that birds use the sun as a compass, taking the time of day into account.1,2 Knut Schmidt-Koenig proved it elegantly in 1958: using artificial light he shifted pigeons' internal clocks, and afterwards they set off predictably in the wrong direction. The sun moves fifteen degrees an hour, so a six-hour shift gives an error of some ninety degrees.3

In experienced pigeons that error is often smaller than predicted. They probably combine the sun with something else.4

The magnetic field

That something else is, among other things, the earth's magnetic field. In 1971 William Keeton stuck small magnets on pigeons' backs. Under a completely overcast sky that made experienced pigeons lose their way, but not under sun; young birds on their first toss were confused even under sun.5 In 1979 Walcott and his colleagues found magnetic material between pigeons' brains and skulls.6

For a long time the sensory cells were thought to be in the upper beak: iron-bearing nerve endings. In 2012 those cells turned out to be macrophages, immune cells, and not nerve cells at all.7 That pigeons do something with the magnetic field is settled. Where and how they sense it, nobody knows for certain.

Scent

In 1972 Italian researchers around Floriano Papi saw that pigeons without a sense of smell no longer oriented homewards from unfamiliar places.8 Later it turned out that in well-trained adult pigeons taking away the sense of smell seriously harmed homing, while cutting the beak nerve, the supposed magnetic route, made no difference.9

Other researchers dispute that smell tells the pigeon anything about where it is. Young birds given artificial odours on the way oriented just as well as ordinary pigeons; in their view smell only switches the navigation system "on".10 That debate is still running.

Infrasound

For years Cornell University's pigeons lost their way when liberated at Jersey Hill in New York State, while pigeons from other lofts had no trouble there. Using sound models, Jonathan Hagstrum worked out that Jersey Hill lies in a "sound shadow" for very low sound, infrasound, from the area of the Cornell loft.11 It is a strong hypothesis, but not proof.

Roads and routes of their own

GPS brought to light something fanciers had always suspected. From 216 GPS tracks around Rome it emerged that experienced pigeons on familiar routes follow motorways and a railway line, sometimes as far as a major junction, even when that is a detour.12

At Oxford researchers saw that near home every pigeon develops its own fixed route, not even the shortest one, and even returns to it when you liberate it beside it.13 Those routes are typically one to two hundred metres wide.14 Pigeons fitted with frosted lenses, which see only light and dark, still flew homewards, but could not find the loft itself.15

At home in a new loft

Flying together

Two pigeons flying together who differ little average their route. If they differ too much, they split, or one becomes the leader. Pairs fly more efficiently than either pigeon alone.16 In flocks of up to ten pigeons there is a clear order of who follows whom.17

And experience is handed on: if you keep replacing one pigeon in a small group with a new one, the route gets better over the "generations", better even than with fixed groups or single birds.18

Sources
  1. G. Kramer, "Wird die Sonnenhöhe bei der Heimfindeorientierung verwertet?", Journal für Ornithologie 94 (1953) 201-219
  2. T. Guilford & G.K. Taylor, "The sun compass revisited", Animal Behaviour 97 (2014) 135-143
  3. K. Schmidt-Koenig, "Experimentelle Einflussnahme auf die 24-Stunden-Periodik bei Brieftauben", Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 15 (1958) 301-331
  4. R. Wiltschko et al., "Pigeon homing: the effect of a clock-shift is often smaller than predicted", Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 35 (1994) 63-73
  5. W.T. Keeton, "Magnets interfere with pigeon homing", PNAS 68 (1971) 102-106
  6. C. Walcott, J.L. Gould & J.L. Kirschvink, "Pigeons have magnets", Science 205 (1979) 1027-1029
  7. C.D. Treiber et al., "Clusters of iron-rich cells in the upper beak of pigeons are macrophages not magnetosensitive neurons", Nature 484 (2012) 367-370
  8. F. Papi et al., "Olfaction and homing in pigeons", Monitore Zoologico Italiano 6 (1972) 85-95; summarised in A. Gagliardo, "Forty years of olfactory navigation in birds", Journal of Experimental Biology 216 (2013) 2165-2171
  9. A. Gagliardo et al., "Navigational abilities of adult and experienced homing pigeons deprived of olfactory or trigeminally mediated magnetic information", Journal of Experimental Biology 212 (2009) 3119-3124
  10. P.E. Jorge et al., "Activational rather than navigational effects of odors on homing of young pigeons", Current Biology 19 (2009) 650-654
  11. J.T. Hagstrum, "Atmospheric propagation modeling indicates homing pigeons use loft-specific infrasonic map cues", Journal of Experimental Biology 216 (2013) 687-699
  12. H.-P. Lipp et al., "Pigeon homing along highways and exits", Current Biology 14 (2004) 1239-1249
  13. D. Biro, J. Meade & T. Guilford, "Familiar route loyalty implies visual pilotage in the homing pigeon", PNAS 101 (2004) 17440-17443
  14. T. Guilford & D. Biro, "Route following and the pigeon's familiar area map", Journal of Experimental Biology 217 (2014) 169-179
  15. K. Schmidt-Koenig & C. Walcott, "Tracks of pigeons homing with frosted lenses", Animal Behaviour 26 (1978) 480-486
  16. D. Biro et al., "From compromise to leadership in pigeon homing", Current Biology 16 (2006) 2123-2128
  17. M. Nagy et al., "Hierarchical group dynamics in pigeon flocks", Nature 464 (2010) 890-893
  18. T. Sasaki & D. Biro, "Cumulative culture can emerge from collective intelligence in animal groups", Nature Communications 8 (2017) 15049